building=* + abandoned=yes is not rendered

[demonbox73]

Describe the idea

Hi excuse me I noticed that this tag
building=* + abandoned=yes is not rendered
and
abandoned:building=* is not rendered too.

Expected behaviour

It's kindly possible to render these tags?

building=* + abandoned=yes

and

abandoned:building=*

Thanks!
--enrico

Alternatives you've considered

None

Context

No response

[mariush444]

similar discussion to #21505
as I understand abandoned:building=* should be use and not building=* + abandoned=yes

[scaidermern]

similar discussion to #21505 as I understand abandoned:building=* should be use and not building=* + abandoned=yes

I'm not quite sure here. An abandoned building is still a building, so building=* + abandoned=yes is equally valid if not even better better than abandoned:building=*.
However, for many other POIs abandoned:key=value should be used according to the lifecycle prefix.

[demonbox73]

similar discussion to #21505 as I understand abandoned:building=* should be use and not building=* + abandoned=yes

I'm not quite sure here. An abandoned building is still a building, so building=* + abandoned=yes is equally valid if not even better better than abandoned:building=*. However, for many other POIs abandoned:key=value should be used according to the lifecycle prefix.

Yes I'm absolutely sure too an abandoned bulding is still a building so it's wrong that it disappear on the rendered map.

Anyway now the situation is this:

building=* + abandoned=yes NOT RENDERED

abandoned:building=* NOT RENDERED

Until about 2 months ago both combinations were rendered, so please the "OsmAnd Team" can fix this issue?
Thanks.

[demonbox73]

Who should be informed about these rendering issues?

[xmd5a2]

Not reproducible. We have some rendering tests for abandoned objects and they are passed correctly. See:

If you observe that some building is not rendered please give us OSM link or coordinates.

[demonbox73]

This object is not rendered:

https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/295356617

[demonbox73]

...and this object is not rendered too:

area:highway=steps

https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/18557625

Thanks

[xmd5a2]

This object is not rendered:
https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/295356617

It is rendered but under quarry. Issue is reproduced.

Regarding area:highway=steps: please don't mix different issues. Please create a separate issue.

[demonbox73]

@xmd5a2

If it is rendered but under quarry. I think that is still an issue to fix. Don't you?

[demonbox73]

@xmd5a2
Thanks

[vshcherb]

@xmd5a2 do you have screenshot? Is this issue related to abanodned or regardless this tag building is rendered under bigger polygon?

[demonbox73]

@xmd5a2 do you have screenshot? Is this issue related to abanodned or regardless this tag building is rendered under bigger polygon?

yes

[demonbox73]

The yellow star WP indicates the position of the building+abandoned=yes